Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

It’s the week of the 2025 NFL Draft (April 24-26 in Green Bay, Wisconsin), so we will soon know exactly how the first round will unfold.

Before the Tennessee Titans go on the clock with the first overall pick Thursday night and draft prospects begin coming off the board, we asked one question:

What is your bold prediction for Round 1 of the 2025 NFL Draft?

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Eric Edholm

Lead Draft Writer

I think it’s possible that four QBs are selected in Round 1. The Saints (facing uncertainty around the availability of Derek Carr) and Steelers (with Aaron Rodgers undecided about his future) are in tough spots, lacking clearly defined starters on their rosters. The Browns and Giants might pass on QBs at Nos. 2 and 3 overall, respectively, but they surely wouldn’t hesitate to move up, if necessary, from the top of Round 2. It might not be a great quarterback class, but that sometimes doesn’t matter.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Chad Reuter

Draft Analyst

Boise State star running back Ashton Jeanty will be picked before Raiders head coach Pete Carroll can make the call at No. 6. The Giants likely have FOMO after watching Saquon Barkley, whom they drafted second overall in 2018, leave to win a Super Bowl with the rival Eagles — and they could use the third overall pick on Jeanty to alleviate that feeling. Or Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel, whose team picks at No. 4, could tab Jeanty to carry the load on offense, as Derrick Henry once did for Vrabel in Tennessee. If Jeanty’s still around at No. 5, the Jaguars could take him as the best player available, or trade out with someone else (the Bears, 49ers, Cowboys or even, if Carroll can’t wait until his original draft slot, Las Vegas) for additional draft capital.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Jeffri Chadiha

NFL.com Columnist

There will be at least seven edge rushers drafted in the first round. This draft is deep in defensive linemen, especially on the edges. There are obviously potential top-10 prospects like Abdul Carter, Jalon Walker and Mykel Williams. There also are exciting talents such as Mike Green, Donovan Ezeiruaku and James Pearce Jr. And there are plenty more after those names. Disrupting the quarterback is critical to success in this league. That’s why it will be hard for several teams to pass on these types of players on Day 1.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Marc Ross

NFL.com Analyst

It’s been almost unanimously assumed during the pre-draft process that Cleveland will select either edge rusher Abdul Carter or two-way player Travis Hunter with the second overall pick. However, early on Thursday night, the Browns provide a shocker when they take QB Shedeur Sanders in that spot.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Lance Zierlein

Draft Analyst

Despite speculation that three quarterbacks could go in the first round (Cam Ward, Shedeur Sanders and Jaxson Dart), my bold take is that we will only see two drafted in Round 1 when it is all said and done. I don’t see the Browns (No. 2), Giants (No. 3), Raiders (No. 6) or Jets (No. 7) taking a quarterback, so that leaves the Saints (No. 9) and Steelers (No. 21) as the most obvious teams to select one after the Titans, who hold the No. 1 overall pick. There is a very real chance that only one of those teams decides to wade into a quarterback pool that appears to be lukewarm, based upon tape and traits. Drafting a quarterback in the first tends to put the jobs of the GM and head coach immediately on the line. I’m just not sure there will be three teams willing to take their chances on a QB on Thursday night.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Maurice Jones-Drew

NFL.com Analyst

You should know by now that I’m a big fan of this year’s running back class — so much so that I think there will be four running backs taken Thursday night, including two in the top 10. Boise State’s Ashton Jeanty is a shoo-in top-10 pick. Then, because there are a number of RB-needy teams picking in the top 10, there’s a chance North Carolina’s Omarion Hampton or Ohio State’s TreVeyon Henderson will be off the board by the time the 49ers go on the clock at No. 11. The other player at the position hearing his name in Round 1 will be Henderson’s Buckeye running mate, Quinshon Judkins.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

David Carr

NFL.com Analyst

I think there will be only one quarterback taken in Round 1: Cam Ward, whom Tennessee will select first overall. I don’t love the fit. Brian Callahan runs a traditional system, with the quarterback leading the offense at the line of scrimmage, which was why Joe Burrow was the perfect signal-caller for Callahan when he was the offensive coordinator in Cincinnati. Ward didn’t operate that kind of offense in college, and I’d argue it’s not what he excels at. The Titans offensive coaching staff is likely going to have to re-invent itself with Ward under center. That said, I don’t think another QB will have his name called before Thursday night winds down.

Bold predictions for Round 1 of 2025 NFL Draft: Browns shock at No. 2? Four RBs taken?

Two tight ends will be selected in the top 10. Wild, I know. I have a full explanation in my Mock Draft … with a Twist!, but here’s the way I see it. There are likely many teams smarting from not taking Brock Bowers last year (looking at you, Jets), to the point that Tyler Warren should be snapped up nice and early (by the Jaguars at No. 5, if you ask me). Then I’d suggest that the Jets (at No. 7) and Panthers (No. 8) take a really good look at Colston Loveland — and I wouldn’t rule out the Bears at No. 10, either. Side take: Matthew Golden should go in the top 10, too. Ah, just click the link.

Related Posts

Browns Warned Against Putting Too Much Faith in Jerry Jeudy as Carnell Tate Sends Message to Cleveland

Cleveland Browns are warned against putting too much emphasis on Jerry Jeudy amid Carnell Tate’s recent message to the franchise. 

Cleveland Browns NFL Combine Takeaways: Fixing Offensive Line is Paramount

After the Cleveland Browns fired Kevin Stefanski, owner Jimmy Haslam stated that the next 120 days would be critical for the future of his team. 55 days later,

Will the Browns make a big move at QB in NFL free agency?

For the second consecutive year, the Cleveland Browns enter an offseason without an unquestioned starter at the quarterback position. The inability to find a starter during the 2025 season…

Kevin Stefanski Reveals When Browns Told Him He Was Being Fired

  Kevin Stefanski has opened up about one of the most difficult moments of his coaching career. The former Cleveland Browns head coach revealed that

How far would Ty Simpson have to fall for the Browns to pull the trigger?

Please enable JS and disable any ad blocker

Browns Deliver Telling Update on Quinshon Judkins

Browns GM Andrew Berry provided an encouraging injury update on running back Quinshon Judkins at the NFL Combine, but Cleveland still has plenty of work to do this offseason.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *